China: Increase in trade credit risk on the horizon?

Barómetro de Prácticas de Pago

  • China
  • Automoción/Transporte,
  • Bienes de consumo duraderos,
  • Electrónica / TIC,
  • Servicios financieros,
  • Máquinas/Ingeniería,
  • Servicios

20 may 2019

Survey respondents in China expect trade credit risk to increase over the coming months. Find out more about their business challenges going forward.

It is too early to say whether the recent improvement in the outlook for China’s economy will be temporary or long lasting. What is certain is that, despite this unexpected trend inversion, the world's second-largest economy will still be facing many challenges in the near future. China’s success in becoming a more consumption led economy and less dependent on export, especially as global demand weakens, should have a significant impact on whether the recent improvement is long lasting. The uncertainties added by the still unsolved trade conflict with the US, the effects of which ripple across the Asia Pacific region, exacerbate the already strained Chinese business environment. Here insolvencies are expected to further increase over the coming months, despite easier access to financing for businesses.

 

Chinese respondents use trade credit more often than in the past to stay competitive

 

Proportion of total B2B sales made on credit in China

 

Survey respondents in China have historically shown a greater preference for selling to their B2B customers on a cash basis than on credit terms. Current survey findings confirm this behaviour; however, they also show a trend of increasing use of trade credit in B2B transactions. 55.7% of the total value of Chinese respondents’ B2B sales was on a cash basis (down from 57.0% last year, and 58.1% in 2017) and 44.3% was on credit terms (up from 43.0% one year ago and from 41.9% in 2017). In response to the domestic economic slowdown and the ongoing global trade tensions, Chinese respondents appear to place more emphasis on the use of trade credit to maintain their competitiveness and gain market share, both domestically and abroad. This is a logical reaction to the more challenging business environment.

 

Perception of trade credit risk is significantly higher in China than in Asia Pacific overall

 

 

 

Despite being more inclined to offer trade credit than in the past, Chinese respondents do not appear similarly inclined to set looser payment terms for their B2B customers. Based on survey findings, most Chinese respondents (85%) requested fast payment of invoices, with terms averaging 26 days (average for the region: 32 days). These are the second shortest in Asia Pacific, after Australia (24 days). The tight payment terms observed in China, which remained almost unchanged over the past year, are at the core of respondents’ strict credit policies. There is clearly recognition of the risks associated with credit sales and the more challenging trade environment. The short terms are used to offset the financial impact of having the cash from higher sales volumes tied up in accounts receivables for an extended period of time.

Check of the buyer’s financial profile done more often in China than in Asia Pacific overall

Consistent with what mentioned earlier on, it is not surprising that Chinese respondents’ credit management policy rotates around the prospective buyer’s financial profile, and its assessment prior to any trade credit decision. On average, Chinese respondents (51%) perform this significantly more often than their Asia Pacific peers do (39%). The same can be said in regards to reserving against bad debts, which is done to offset potentially inaccurate screening of the buyer’s financial position (37% of respondents in China vs. 33% at regional level) and to monitoring the credit risk associated with buyers  (32% of respondents in China vs. 29% in Asia Pacific). Of note is that a staggering 36% of Chinese respondents reported to have decided to self-insure over the past year (well above the 23% of respondents in Asia Pacific).

Payment behaviour in China worsened significantly over the past year

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Payment duration in China

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Over the past year, there was a significant increase in the value of overdue and uncollectable invoices in China. This is reflected in an average 36.3% of the total value of B2B invoices issued by survey respondents remaining unpaid at the due date (well above the 29.8% regional average). On average, it takes respondents from China 18 days longer than the invoice due date to turn these overdue invoices into cash (no marked change over the past year). In order to remain financially sound and avoid liquidity issues caused by buyers paying late, most Chinese respondents (45%) reported they were forced to delay payment of invoices to their own suppliers and to take various measures to correct cash flow (40%). 3 in 10 respondents pursued additional financing from external sources to reduce financial pressure on the business. On the more positive side, 1.9% of B2B receivables were written-off as uncollectable (2.1% regional average), the same as one year ago.

Chinese respondents expect trade credit risk to increase over the coming months 

Most Chinese respondents (46%) do not expect payment practices of B2B customers to change over the coming months. 22% anticipate an improvement, while 31% expect a worsening in the form of an increase in late payments including in long overdue invoices (more than 90 days overdue). To protect their business against the risk of payment default by their customers, 48% of Chinese respondents will increase their use of credit management software over the next 12 months. 46% will increase the usage of self-insurance, while 45% will perform more regular checks of their buyers’ creditworthiness, and more actively reserve against bad debts. Of note, nearly 30% will begin offering discounts for early settlement of invoices. This within the frame of already short payment terms.

Overview of payment practices in China

By business sector / industry

Longest average payment terms in the services and ICT/electronics sectors. Shortest in the wholesale/retail/distribution and consumer durables sectors.

Chinese respondents from both the services and the ICT/electronics sectors extended the longest average payment terms (averaging 43 days and 31 days from the invoice date respectively). The shortest average payment terms were extended by respondents in the wholesale/retail/distribution and the consumer durables sectors (averaging 24 days and 22 days respectively).

Trade credit risk is high in the Chinese manufacturing, machines and construction sectors

The value of overdue invoices in the Chinese services sector amounts to 23.3% of the total value of B2B invoices issued by Chinese respondents. This compares to an average of 41.7% in the manufacturing sector and of 29.9% in the wholesale/retail/distribution sector. Both the machines and the construction sectors recorded high of 42.0% of past due invoices, while the chemicals sector a low of 22.9%.

For 2019 we expect real GDP growth to reach 6.2%. This still means a growth slowdown from last year, but the original soft landing scenario is intact

Source: Atradius Economic Outlook

Proportion of uncollectable receivables highest in the manufacturing sector and in the consumer durables industry

The manufacturing, consumer durables, machines, construction and agri-food sectors in China all reported that 2.1% of their B2B receivables were written off as uncollectable, the highest proportion in the country. At the other end of the scale, the wholesale/retail/distribution and services sectors reported that 1.5% of their B2B receivables were written off as uncollectable and ICT/electronics, that 1.1% was written off.

 

By business size

SMEs in China extended the longest average payment terms to B2B customers

Respondents from SMEs in China extended the longest and those from large enterprises the shortest average payment terms to B2B customers (averaging 28 days and 21 days from the invoice date respectively).  This emphasises the relative leverage that the supplier has in the transaction.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Uncollectable B2B receivables in China

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Chinese SMEs took the longest to cash on overdue invoices

Over the past year, large enterprises in China recorded the highest increase in the proportion of B2B invoices paid on time (+25% on average). Due to this change, overdue invoices in large enterprises now account for 35.2% of the total value of B2B invoices. In contrast, on time payment of the B2B invoices of SMEs decreased 8% on average. The average time it takes to convert invoices into cash is 46 days from the invoice date for SMEs and 39 days for large enterprises.

 

Chinese SMEs recorded the highest rate of uncollectable receivables

SMEs in China recorded the highest proportion (2.1%) of B2B receivables written off as uncollectable. The average for large enterprises is 1.6% and for micro-enterprises 1.4%.

Disclaimer y Buró de Entidades Financieras

Este informe se presenta, con fines de información únicamente y no está pensada como una recomendación en cuanto a las transacciones particulares, inversiones o estrategias en modo alguno a cualquier lector. Los lectores deben tomar sus propias decisiones independientes, comerciales o de cualquier otro tipo, con respecto a la información proporcionada. Aunque hemos hecho todo lo posible para garantizar que la información contenida en este informe sea obtenida de fuentes confiables, Atradius no es responsable por los errores u omisiones, o por los resultados obtenidos del uso de esta información. En ningún caso Atradius, sus corporaciones o empresas relacionadas, afiliadas y subsidiarias, ni los socios, agentes o empleados, serán responsables por cualquier decisión o medida adoptada con base en la información en este informe, o por ningún daño directo, indirecto, especial, incidental o consecuente, resultante del uso de la información de las declaraciones hechas en este documento. BURÓ DE ENTIDADES FINANCIERAS ¿Qué es el Buró de Entidades Financieras? Es una herramienta de consulta y difusión con la que podrás conocer los productos que ofrecen las entidades financieras, sus comisiones y tasas, las reclamaciones de los usuarios, las prácticas no sanas en que incurren, las sanciones administrativas que les han impuesto, las cláusulas abusivas de sus contratos y otra información que resulte relevante para informarte sobre su desempeño. Con el Buró de Entidades Financieras, se logrará saber quién es quién en bancos, seguros, sociedades financieras de objeto múltiple, cajas de ahorro, afores, entre otras entidades. Con ello, podrás comparar y evaluar a las entidades financieras, sus productos y servicios y tendrás mayores elementos para elegir lo que más te convenga. Esta información te será útil para elegir un producto financiero y también para conocer y usar mejor los que ya tienes. Este Buró de Entidades Financieras, es una herramienta que puede contribuir al crecimiento económico del país, al promover la competencia entre las instituciones financieras; que impulsará la transparencia al revelar información a los usuarios sobre el desempeño de éstas y los productos que ofrecen y que va a facilitar un manejo responsable de los productos y servicios financieros al conocer a detalle sus características. Lo anterior, podrá derivar en un mayor bienestar social, porque al conjuntar en un solo espacio tan diversa información del sistema financiero, el usuario tendrá más elementos para optimizar su presupuesto, para mejorar sus finanzas personales, para utilizar correctamente los créditos que fortalecerán su economía y obtener los seguros que la protejan, entre otros aspectos. Puedes consultar la información relativa al Buró de Entidades Financieras, tanto de Atradius Seguros de Crédito. S.A., como de todo el sector asegurador en el siguiente enlace: http://www.buro.gob.mx